emfizz.com December 14, 2017

Kennedy Sends Mixed Messages in Supreme Court Cake Case

06 December 2017, 01:06 | Terri Saunders

The US Supreme Court Just Rejected a Texas Case About Gay Marriage Rights

Pamela Holwerds holds up her marriage license following the ceremony that married over 40 same-sex couples on the south lawn of the Texas Capitol in Austin

The Supreme Court appeared divided down the middle Tuesday over a Colorado baker's refusal to design a wedding cake for a same-sex couple, the latest test in the continuing legal battle between gay rights and religious expression.

In the first, which the Supreme Court considered this morning, the Colorado Civil Rights Division ruled that a cake shop could not refuse to make a wedding cake for a gay couple, calling it discriminatory, because its refusal was based upon the sexual orientation of the customers.

Mr Mullins and Mr Craig continue to argue that they have been discriminated against.

The Trump administration and many other conservative campaigners support this position.

"It means that there's basically an ability to boycott gay marriages", said the author of the 2015 opinion extending same-sex marriage nationwide.

Early in a riveting argument at the high court Tuesday, Kennedy anxious that a ruling for baker Jack Phillips might allow stores to post signs that they "do not bake cakes for gay weddings". The 81-year-old justice expressed concern about an "affront to the gay community".

Francisco replied that there "are dignity interests on the other side here, too".

The commission ruled that Phillips violated the state's anti-discrimination law when he refused to make a wedding cake for Charlie Craig and David Mullins.

But later he said Colorado had been "neither tolerant nor respectful" of the religious views of Denver-area baker Jack Phillips.

Supporters of both sides gathered for days outside the court for the chance to watch the session and were out in force on Tuesday.

"This case is about more than us, and it's not about cakes", Mullins said in a meeting.

Truckers protest electronic logging device mandate
Bill Shuster, R-Pa. "On paper logs, it costs eight dollars per truck per month to operate a truck on logs right now". That resolution has been idling in the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee, which is chaired by U.S.

Oklahoma star RB facing rape allegation
The petition says Anderson, 21, walked the woman home after meeting her for the first time at a bar and drinking. Anderson did not reciprocate a desire to pursue a relationship with (the woman)", the statement said.

Gujarat polls: PM Modi's Wednesday rally postponed in view of cyclone Ochki
Mumbai and its surrounding districts experienced nearly continuous rain with bouts of heavy showers since Monday evening. Fishermen bring in their boats at the coast of Mumbai , near the Bandra-Worli Sea Link.

By all appearances, the case will divide the justices along ideological lines. A jeweler? A makeup artist?

No, Waggoner said, "because it is not speech". Kagan wanted to know: "Why is there no speech in creating a wonderful hairdo?" and "Where would you put a tailor?" "A custom wedding cake is not an ordinary baked good; its function is more communicative and artistic than utilitarian", Solicitor General Noel Francisco argued. "That's what everybody is trying to get to".

After being denied a custom cake, Craig and Mullins filed a complaint against Phillips with Colorado's Civil Rights Commission.

Flash forward to 2012, when same sex marriage was not yet legal in Colorado, but two men walked into the bakery. "I would not like to utilize my aesthetic gifts to make something that conflicted with my Christian confidence", he said in a meeting, noticing that he has additionally declined to make cakes to observe Halloween. That struck him as unfair, he said.

Phillips at that point took his case to the Supreme Court and the judges consented to take it up in the wake of reflecting on it for a little while.

"(But) no one is suggesting that the baker has to march in the parade", Cole said.

"I serve all who walk through my doors, people from all walks of life", Phillips told Colorado Public Radio.

To refuse to sell any t-shirt to a person simply because he is gay would violate the statute, whereas refusing to print a t-shirt which promote a gay lifestyle or activities, for anyone regardless of sexual orientation, is not illegal discrimination.

In one of the most animated oral arguments the high court has held, justices on both sides peppered four lawyers with questions to illustrate how their decision might affect other merchants, such as chefs and florists, and other minority groups, such as Catholics and African Americans.

Lawyers for Jack Phillips relied on two parts of the First Amendment - free exercise and free speech - to make his case, and at times Kennedy seemed torn during the lively and sometimes rapid-fire arguments.

Other News

Trending Now

John Mayer Has Been Hospitalised For Emergency Surgery
John Mayer underwent an emergency appendectomy Tuesday morning, forcing the rocker to postpone a New Orleans Dead & Company show. Dead & Company is now next scheduled to perform on Thursday at the Amway Center in Orlando , FL.

Bitcoin Regulation: Why the UK Treasury Stepping in Will Not Stop Criminals
Coincidence? I think not! "This, in turn, will motivate companies to more effectively self-police bad actors". The government's aim is part of a broader update to the European Union rules which are under negotiation.

Google to issue warnings when apps steal your personal data
The company did not say whether the new policy of privacy violation warnings will apply to its own software as well. It must also be displayed within the normal usage of the app and not be buried in settings.

Honor 7X launched in India, prices start from Rs 12999: Specifications here
It is powered by a Kirin 970 processor and comes with the Neural Processing Unit (NPU) for improved artificial intelligence. Huawei was actually the one that started the whole dual-camera fad this time around, and it looks like its here to stay.

Asus, HP Debut Snapdragon-Powered Windows Laptops
These devices are deigned to be always on like your phone and Asus says the NovaGo will offer more than 30 days of standby time. At Qualcomm's Snapdragon Summit in Hawaii, the first Windows 10 laptop running on Snapdragon has been announced .

North Korea: US 'begging' for war with 'largest ever' joint aerial drill
Such language is typical in North Korean propaganda because the country claims U.S. Air Force spokesman could not confirm the reports.

United Nations envoy not carrying USA government message on North Korea visit
Dujarric said Pyongyang issued an invitation for Feltman to visit back in September, during the annual gathering of world leaders at the U.N.

Destiny 2 expansion pack Curse of Osiris gets launch trailer, now available
The company is taking the game offline for around three hours to perform the maintenance, which applies to PS4, Xbox One , and PC. Curse of Osiris continues your Guardian's journey with all-new story missions and adventures set in a new destination, Mercury.

Disney Resumes Talks to Buy Most of 21st Century Fox's Assets
The company reported $0.49 earnings per share for the quarter, beating the Thomson Reuters' consensus estimate of $0.48 by $0.01. ILLEGAL ACTIVITY NOTICE: This article was published by The Lincolnian Online and is the property of of The Lincolnian Online.

Jeremy Hunt hits out at Facebook kids' app
Facebook won't show ads in Messenger Kids or use data from the app to target ads elsewhere, according to a company representative. YouTube has recently received criticism over concerns with its Kids app, which features videos tailored toward children.